November 7, 2009

House Health Care Reform Bill Passes: 220-215

The passage is bittersweet, but finally it’s done … With 6:51 time remaining to vote, Democrats have secured the 218 “yea” votes needed to pass the Affordable Health Care for America Act (HR 3962).

Final tally 220-215; 39 Democrats voted “no.” One Republican — Rep. Joseph Cao, who represents the New Orleans area — voted “yea.”

“Democrats have sought for decades to provide universal health care, but not since the 1965 passage of Medicare and Medicaid has a chamber of Congress approved such a vast expansion of coverage,” reports the Washington Post. “Action now shifts to the Senate, which could spend the rest of the year debating its version of the health-care overhaul. Majority Leader Harry M. Reid (D-Nev.) hopes to bring a measure to the floor before Thanksgiving, but legislation may not reach Obama’s desk before the new year.”

As I watched Democrats congratulate themselves, it was difficult to feel celebratory. Passage of the Stupak amendment — which bars a government-run insurance plan from offering abortion *and* prohibits women who receive government insurance subsidies from purchasing private plans that include abortion coverage — sucked a lot of the energy out of the room.

As Princeton professor Melissa Harris Lacewell said on Twitter, “Stupak feels like Prop 8 [which overturned same-sex marriage in California the same night President Obama was elected]. When the ‘win’ is accompanied by legislation that attacks the most marginal it doesn’t feel like a win.”

For a look at how each House member voted, check out this Washington Post graphic. You can sort the list by how much money each member has received in campaign contributions from the health industry and by the percent of people without health insurance in each district . The New York Times does a nice job of showing the geography of the vote (mouseover the states to reveal individual districts).

We close tonight with a reminder of what this bill provides — and the work still left to be done. Read Maggie Mahar’s in-depth post “Heath Care Reform — Looking at the Glass Half-Full.” The National Women’s Law Center breaks down what this bill means for women in every state.


4 Responses to “House Health Care Reform Bill Passes: 220-215”

  1. Marly Says:

    Great commentary on the healthcare reform bill. I hope it is a step in the right direction!

  2. Joanne Barker Says:

    Thank you, Our Bodies Ourselves, for being on top of this and being a strong voice for women’s health. It’s been a long road to get here and we still have a long road ahead.

  3. Maguire Says:

    It is a bittersweet moment. The focus of this bill is 2 pronged, and I only hope that it will actually bring about positive changes, however the focus of this bill has missed the initial intention. Health care is the debate, and insurance is the only thing on the table.
    The insurance companies have no control over the cost of medical expenses and are constantly trying to both pay for services rendered as well as make a profit.
    In an interview, Dr Eva Mor, author of ‘Making the Golden Years Golden’, states that “What we need in a health system is uniformity in pricing for procedures and services and modalities of provision of testing and procedures for diagnosis and treatment. By providing coverage to the uninsured, which initially will cost the taxpayer, it eventually will save us hundreds of millions of dollars.”http://www.ourblook.com/component/option,com_sectionex/Itemid,200076/id,8/view,category/#catid107
    Without some sort of regulation over procedural costs, there is no uniformity or stability to the system. Reigning in profiteering within the industry could save in the long run and lower costs across the board.

  4. georgia Says:

    See this article in On The Issues Magazine- it says health care is the first of all liberties.

    “It’s critical for reproductive justice advocates to also become health care advocates in today’s world…”

    Read the rest here: http://www.ontheissuesmagazine.com/2009fall/2009fall_pandit.php

Leave a Reply

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word